Screengrab of the NNML banner with 3 books to celebrate Low Vision Awareness Month: Haben by Haben Girma, There Plant Eyes by M. Leona Godin, and The Impending Blindness of Billie Scott by Zoe Thorogood. Also includes a lead quote from me: “You’re either kind of a super blind person or you’re kind of on the other end of the spectrum, kind of a pitiable blind person, and a lot of what I try and do in the book is kind of looking at the middle, you know, the vast middle ground of most of us who are just living our lives, you know, as mothers and people who work and teach and all those sorts of things.” - M. Leona Godin, author of February featured book “There Plant Eyes: A Personal and Cultural history of Blindness” from Blind Abilities.

Reading Club Discussion Guide for ‘There Plant Eyes’

February is Low Vision Awareness Month, and I’m honored that There Plant Eyes was chosen as one of 3 Reading Club books by the NNLM (Network of the National Library of Medicine). Here’s the announcement, and here’s TPE featured plus other vision resources. Below is the discussion guide I created for them. I hope it will be useful for other clubs and classes.

Introduction

“[A] thought-provoking mixture of criticism, memoir, and advocacy.” —The New Yorker

For millennia, blindness has been used to signify thoughtlessness (“blind faith”), irrationality (“blind rage”), and unconsciousness (“blind evolution”). But at the same time, blind people have been othered as the recipients of special powers as compensation for lost sight (from the poetic gifts of John Milton to the heightened senses of the comic book hero Daredevil). Combining analyses of blindness in art, culture, and history with her own story of gradually losing her sight, in this genre-defying work, M. Leona Godin probes the ways in which blindness has shaped our ocularcentric world, and challenges deeply ingrained ideas about what it really means to be “blind.”

A vivid personal and cultural history, There Plant Eyes explores the fascinating history of blindness—from Homer to Helen Keller, from Dune to Stevie Wonder, and from the invention of braille to the science of echolocation. And in doing so, Godin reveals just how essential blindness and vision are to our understanding of ourselves and the world around us.

Questions and Topics for Discussion

The following questions and topics are designed to spark thoughtful and lively discussion for your book club’s reading of There Plant Eyes. We hope they enhance your experience of this important book.

  1. Godin begins this sweeping narrative with some personal history. How does the introductory chapter, “Seeing and Not-Seeing” lay the groundwork for the chapters to come?
  2. Chapters 1 and 2 focus on the blind poet/prophet of ancient Greece. Why do you think Godin chose to begin with these ancient texts? Were you persuaded that misconceptions surrounding blindness stretch back so far?
  3. Throughout the book, Godin weaves personal anecdotes with her larger cultural themes of blindness through the centuries. Did you find these anecdotes useful? Did they help you to relate the older or more obscure texts to today?
  4. What does the term “ocularcentrism” mean? How does it relate to the larger themes of the book?
  5. Where does the title There Plant Eyes come from? What does it mean and what’s its significance?
  6. The reader is often addressed directly in There Plant Eyes. Do you think this refers to a blind or sighted reader? What makes you choose one or the other? Do you think the message of the book is the same for blind and sighted readers?
  7. Discuss your own experience of knowing, meeting, or encountering a blind person, or of experiencing temporary or permanent blindness yourself.
  8. There Plant Eyes gives many examples of the metaphoric extremes of being either poets/prophets or superheroes on the one hand, and being beggars and buffoons on the other. How do these extremes impact the lives of actual blind people?
  9. Blindness is often depicted as a calamity. Do you think this attitude shapes the way you personally deal with blindness or blind people? Why are our representations of blind people in the media so wrong? Do you think There Plant Eyes will change the way you perceive blind characters in books or movies? Why or why not?
  10. In chapters 8 and 9, Godin explores the history of blind education and how it was intimately connected with larger European ideals of progress and enlightenment. What did you find interesting or surprising about this history?
  11. Godin writes: “There are as many ways of being blind as there are of being sighted” (272-3). How did reading There Plant Eyes complicate your idea of what blindness is? Did you learn anything surprising about what or how blind people see?
  12. A common thread in the book is that “impressions about blindness . . . are far more threatening to blind people than the blindness itself.” As sonar expert Daniel Kish, puts it on page 169. What do you think about that proposition? What can you personally do to shift negative impressions of blindness? What can society do?
  13. Were you familiar with the term “inspiration porn”? Have you encountered such depictions in the media? Why are they so detrimental to the lives of blind and disabled people?
  14. How does There Plant Eyes relate blindness to larger issues facing disabled people? Had you ever heard of disability pride? What do you think of the disability pride movement? Can you relate it to other pride movements?
  15. There Plant Eyes provides insights into the ableism and discrimination blind people face in their careers, personal lives, and artistic ambitions. How do you think gender, race, and sexuality intersect with blindness and other disabilities?
  16. In the book’s closing chapter, what truths about blindness were distilled as we look ahead to a future that is less ableist, less ocularcentric?? Do you think blind pride is possible?
  17. In the final chapter, Godin discusses problems of language. Do you agree with her that language matters? Does her argument inspire you to change the way you employ the word “blind” or to be more sensitive to ableist language in general?
  18. What is original about There Plant Eyes? How does it distinguish itself from other books you have read on blindness or disability?
  19. Godin quotes many blind people in There Plant Eyes. Whose story were you most curious about? Are there people whose memoirs or biographies you now feel inspired to read?

Recommended Readings

The World I Live In and Midstream by Helen Keller

Face of the Deep and Sound of the Walls by Jacob Twersky

Touching the Rock by John Hull

Planet of the Blind and Eavesdropping by Stephen Kuusisto

The Mind’s Eye by Oliver Sacks

A Sense of the World by Jason Roberts

See What I’m Saying by Lawrence Rosenblum

Haben by Haben Girma

Blind Man’s Bluff by James Tate Hill

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *